Delay to ‘fish discards’ rule undermines sustainability efforts, say Greens

The parliamentary committee ruled that extra time was necessary to help fisheries adapt to the discard ban

MEPs have delayed a ban on throwing back unwanted fish catches in a vote that European Greens say undermines rules intended to improve sustainability.

The draft law, which was approved by 573 votes to 96 with 21 abstentions, gives fisheries two years before sanctions will take effect for failing to comply. The discards rule was part of a newly reformed Common Fisheries Policy, which meant fisheries would have to land all fish caught during a fishing trip – the intention being to encourage more selective use of fishing equipment to avoid unwanted catches.

Following the vote, rapporteur and Fisheries Committee chair Alain Cadec (EPP, FR) said: "It will be extremely difficult to implement, especially for multi-species and artisanal fisheries. Our common concern is to preserve fisheries resources while maintaining a viable economy. The agreement we have found helps mitigate some of the negative effects of the new rules for fishermen.”

However, Green fisheries spokesperson Linnéa Engström said: "The new rules voted today would totally undercut the ban on discards and essential give unscrupulous fishermen a carte blanche to continue with the wasteful practice. The ink is hardly dry on the EU's much-lauded reform of the Common Fisheries Policy but one of the crucial achievements is already being unpicked. This is a major setback for efforts to make our fishing industry more sustainable.”

The new rule will allow fisheries to discard fish if they consider them to be damaged or diseased.

Engström added: "This undermines the essence of the landing obligation, which was to make fishermen responsible for landing their catch, with a view to incentivising the choice of more selective fishing equipment. Instead fishermen will continue to be allowed to throw fish overboard and thus bypass the obligation.”

A discard ban has already been in force since January 1 2015 for pelagic species, such as herring, sardines and southern bluefin tuna, and seven current EU regulations conflict with the new rules, the European Parliament said, meaning that extra time was needed to adapt.

The ban is set to take place gradually until 2019.

Additionally, the Commission must provide an annual report on landing of unwanted catches, and the requirement to keep undersized fish separately by species was removed, among other provisions.

The EU Council of Ministers must now vote on the draft law, which will then enter the EU Official Journal before becoming law.

Related News

Conversion of fish waste to flavours could be commercially viable, say researchers

Conversion of fish waste to flavours could be commercially viable, say researchers

Fishy business: Europe paid 600% too much for foreign fish, say auditors

Fishy business: Europe paid 600% too much for foreign fish, say auditors

The project: 'Maximising yield of fisheries while balancing ecosystem, economic and social concerns,' was set up to tackle challenges of meeting the European Common Fisheries Policy’s (CFP) goals. ©iStock

Maximum sustainable yield frameworks need to be adaptive, Myfish concludes

The report describes the The Mediterranean Sea as 'under siege' because of intense pressures from multiple human activities that include overfishing..©iStock/Typhoonski

Mediterranean overfishing risks reaching ‘a point of no return,’ report warns

This increase in anthropogenic pressure, along with climate change, threatens the biodiversity of fishes and food security. ©iStock

Higher marine food demand places big fish on ‘at risk’ list, study finds

Fish manufacturers should voluntarily improve labelling - or risk boycott

Fish manufacturers should voluntarily improve labelling - or risk boycott

Eco-labels are often a way for food companies to demonstrate that they are fulfilling their promises, Sahota said

Sustainability standards in the spotlight: ‘Still taking baby steps’

EU fish discards ‘difficult for industry to comply with’

EU fish discards ‘difficult for industry to comply with’

Almost 30% of global fish stocks are overfished, according to the report

Guide urges industry action on ‘pirate’ fish

Related Products

See more related products

Comments (1)

Max - 17 May 2015 | 12:08

Someone has still some brain space left

Finally initiative has been taken to stop the foolishness of the "so much lauded reform of th CFP". Hope some other stupid fisheries rules will be stopped soon as well.

17-May-2015 at 12:08 GMT

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.