Sugar-restricted diet hits certain cancers harder: Study

'We'd like to know from a scientific standpoint whether we might be able to affect cancer progression with dietary changes,' said lead author Dr Kim. © iStock

A low-sugar diet may affect the speed at which certain cancer cells spread after a study finds some types rely more on sugar as an energy source than others do. 

Research teams found the squamous cell carcinoma (SqCC), a type of lung cancer, used more sugar in its growth when compared to an adenocarcinoma (ADC), another non-small cell lung cancer.

“These findings lend credence to the idea that cancer is not just one disease, but many diseases that have very different characteristics,” said Dr Jung-whan "Jay" Kim, assistant professor of biological sciences at the University of Texas and senior author of the study.

“We'd like to know whether we might be able to affect cancer progression with dietary changes," he added.

Evidence is mounting over the last decade that certain types of cancer are more sugar-hungry than others are.

Its role in the nation’s health has formed the backdrop of policies designed to restrict its consumption amongst a country’s population.

Along with cancer, sugar is also linked to an increased risk of dental caries, overweight and cardio-metabolic risk factors and mortality.

Since 2014, Nordic Nutrition Recommendations have taken on board guidance, which recommends cutting sugar to less than 10% of total energy intake for children and adults.

The UK has adopted in 2015 an even more demanding threshold, with a recommended intake of less than 5% of dietary energy as free sugars.

Most other countries, such as the Netherlands, have not set quantitative reference intakes, but mention that 20% of the energy as added sugars may be detrimental to nutrition and health.

Greedy GLUT1

The study centres on the protein GLUT1 – a transporter responsible for carrying glucose into cells.

GLUT1 is also responsible for providing the sugar for energy that fuels cell metabolism, function and building cell membranes.

Experiments using human non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) tumour samples, patient-derived xenografts, mice models of NSCLC and NSCLC cell lines found an increased level of GLUT1 activity in the lung SqCC.

"We looked at this from several different experimental angles, and consistently, GLUT1 was highly active in the squamous subtype of cancer. Adenocarcinoma is much less dependent on sugar," Kim said.

"When we gave GLUT1 inhibitors to mice with lung cancer, the squamous cancer diminished, but not the adenocarcinoma," Kim said. "There was not a complete eradication, but tumour growth slowed.

Additional trials found GLUT1 levels to be elevated in a number of squamous cell cancers that include head and neck, oesophageal and cervical.

"These are very different organs and tissues in the body, but somehow squamous cell cancers have a very similar commonality in terms of glucose uptake," Kim said.

"This type of cancer clearly consumes a lot of sugar. One of our next steps is to look at why this is the case."

Sugar consumption levels

Despite government efforts, sugar consumption remains alarmingly high, particularly amongst children and young adults.

Worldwide intake of free sugars varies by age, setting and country.

In Europe, intake in adults ranges from about 7-8% of total energy intake in countries like Hungary and Norway, to 16-17% in countries like Spain and the UK.

Intake is much higher among children, ranging from about 12% in countries like Denmark, Slovenia and Sweden, to nearly 25% in Portugal.

Source: Nature Communications

Published online ahead of print: doi:10.1038/ncomms15503

“The distinct metabolic phenotype of lung squamous cell carcinoma defines selective vulnerability to glycolytic inhibition.”

Authors: Jung-whan Kim et al.

Related News

Coconut sugar is made from the sap of flowers from the palm

Coconut sugar: The latest sugar alternative

Sugar and obesity: AB Sugar says singling out sugar is 'misleading'

‘Misleading’ to single out sugar as a lead cause of obesity, says AB Sugar

British Sugar welcomes WHO added sugar guidance – with a caveat

British Sugar welcomes WHO added sugar guidance – with a caveat

How rapidly can industry cut sugar?

Action on Sugar sketches sugar reduction plans

European sugar users welcome debate on sugar reform

European sugar users welcome debate on sugar reform

Related Products

See more related products

Comments (2)

Gerald Davies - 02 Jun 2017 | 09:08

The study was about glucose not sugar

Most of the glucose (blood sugar) in the diet comes from carbohydrates and in most people much less from sucrose (sugar). Talk about sugar restriction and not starch restriction is totally missing the point

02-Jun-2017 at 21:08 GMT

Laurel - 01 Jun 2017 | 07:10

whats new?

the so called "crazies" ie the alt health people have known this for some time. and been ridiculed or ignored. I guess specificity from this is useful. how do you find a cancer? inject radioactive dye with sugar, and where the sugar gets drawn for higher use seems to be the cancer from readings ive done.

01-Jun-2017 at 19:10 GMT

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.