Sensory satisfaction seduces people to choose smaller portions

'When choosing based on sensory pleasure, people tend to order smaller portions...' ©iStock/Stacey Newman

It’s a case of quality over quantity as research suggests people will pay more for smaller portions if the food can successfully appeal to their sense of taste, smell and texture.

Multisensory imagery was used on test subjects who assessed portions on degree of sensory pleasure as opposed to hunger.

In contrast a selection based on health resulted in those choosing a smaller portion than the one they expected to enjoy most.

The researchers enquired as to how people can be encouraged to choose — and actually prefer — smaller food portions.

The rise of ‘supersizing’ has led governments and public health institutions to consider portion size limits and tighter food labelling.

Such efforts have had limited success to date as many consumers maintain eating habits to the pleasure of food marketers who typically extract higher profits from larger portions.

Five food findings

In the first of five experiments carried out at INSEAD Sorbonne Behavioural Lab in France, the authors asked French and US adults and children to use their five senses in imagining the pleasure of eating desserts. When asked to choose portions of brownies, they chose ones that were two sizes smaller than the portions chosen by children in a control condition.

In another experiment, the authors then described a chocolate cake as smelling of ‘roasted coffee’ with ‘aromas of honey and vanilla’ with an ‘aftertaste of blackberry’ to 190 adult Americans. When asked to choose, they consistently selected a smaller portion compared to those where the cake was described as ‘chocolate cake.’

Additionally, when subjects were told about the calorie and fat content of each cake portion, they choose a smaller portion, but only if it were cheaper (by around €1) compared to the multisensory condition.

The final study, which assessed how much subjects would enjoy either small or large portions of chocolate brownies found that both were enjoyed equally. This was eliminated by multisensory imagery, which made people better forecasters of their own future eating enjoyment.

“We show in our studies that marketing labels that emphasise the sensory quality of foods, change people's criterion of choice of portion sizes,” said Dr Yann Cornil, assistant professor of Marketing, Sauder School of Business, University of British Columbia in Canada.

“When choosing based on sensory pleasure, people tend to order smaller portions, and are willing to pay at least as much for these smaller portions than for larger portions.”

”This means that there are opportunities for the food industry to move toward more qualitative business models that focus more on the sensory quality of foods, and less on the quantity at lowest cost. The food industry could therefore grow without contributing to the obesity crisis.”

‘Stop caricaturing eating enjoyment’

Along with co-study author Dr Pierre Chandon, L’Or´eal chaired professor of Marketing, Innovation and Creativity, INSEAD, Fontainebleau, France, the researchers pointed out that the current obesity epidemic is largely driven by ever-increasing food portion sizes.

“Public policy and related research efforts have tended to focus on what people chose to eat rather than how much they choose to eat,” the study noted.

“Our findings suggest that it is time to stop caricaturing eating enjoyment as the simple fulfilment of visceral impulses and to rehabilitate the pleasure of eating, as experienced in countries such as France and Italy, where the prevalence of obesity and eating disorders is noticeably low.”

Source: Journal of Marketing Research

Published online ahead of print, DOI: 10.1509/jmr.14.0299

“Pleasure as a Substitute for Size: How Multisensory Imagery Can Make People Happier with Smaller Food Portions.”

Authors: Yann Cornil and Pierre Chandon

Related News

Size perception and social image concerns are cues that may provide strategies for promoting healthy behavior. ©iStock/memoriesarecaptured

Portion limit strategies no guarantee in reducing sugar drink intake

Examining nutrition labels is often recommended by doctors and dietitians to improve food choices, but choice does not always translate to consumption. ©iStock/piotr_malczyk

Food quality, not quantity matters to label lovers

Food manufacturers are under pressure to implement strategies to promote choices that fall within an appropriate range for energy needs. (image:

Empower portion size choice to the consumer, says study

Portion sizes have increased in many food categories over the past 20 years

What’s an average serving? Portion size guidance ‘no longer fit for purpose’

Cookies sold in packs of three give calorie and nutrition information for a single cookie serving - but who only eats one cookie? Consumers are being mislead says MEP Mairead McGuinness and EU consumer group BEUC. © iStock

Portion distortion: The EU must define realistic portion sizes, says MEP

Half portions to count towards ‘five-a-day’

Related Products

See more related products

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.