Dietary guidelines are wrong on saturated fats, claims cardiovascular researcher

Dietary guidelines are wrong on saturated fats, claims cardiovascular researcher

Recommendations to replace saturated fat with carbohydrates or polyunsaturated fat are “severely challenged” and should be revised, claims an editorial published in Open Heart, a new journal from the BMJ Group.

James DiNicolantonio, a cardiovascular research scientist and doctor of pharmacy at Ithaca, New York, builds on a previous commentary published in the British Medical Journal in October, in which cardiologist Aseem Malhotra claimed saturated fat in meat and dairy had been unfairly demonised. In particular, the two cardiovascular experts both claim that saturated fat is not as bad for heart health as the public has been led to believe.

“The benefits of a low-fat diet (particularly a diet replacing saturated fats with carbohydrates or omega-6 polyunsaturated fatty acids) are severely challenged,” wrote DiNicolantonio. “Dietary guidelines should assess the totality of the evidence and strongly reconsider their recommendations for replacing saturated fats with carbohydrates or omega-6 polyunsaturated fats.”

Refined carbs

DiNicolantonio claims that increased intake of refined carbohydrates, including sugar, is actually to blame for a rapid increase in type-2 diabetes and obesity. He says dietary guidelines to reduce saturated fat intake were based on a flawed premise that saturated fat increased total cholesterol, and ignored evidence that replacing saturated fat with carbohydrate could worsen overall blood lipid profiles.

In addition, he says advice to replace saturated fats with polyunsaturated fats, without specifying omega-3s, may also have had harmful effects on heart health.

“Dietary guideline recommendations suggesting the replacement of saturated fat with carbohydrates/omega-6 polyunsaturated fats do not reflect the current evidence in the literature,” he wrote. “A change in these recommendations is drastically needed as public health could be at risk.”

Processed foods ‘should be avoided’

As for implications for the food industry, DiNicolantonio writes: “It would be naive to assume that any recommendations related to carbohydrate or fat intake would apply to processed foods, which undoubtedly should be avoided if possible.”

Commenting on the article, Professor of Nutrition at Robert Gordon University, Aberdeen, Brian Ratcliffe, said it was a welcome addition to the debate about dietary fat. However, he said DiNicolantonio’s assertion that refined carbohydrates and increased consumption of sugars in the USA were to blame was ‘simplistic’.

“The latter has occurred across much of the developed world without such obvious associations with dietary carbohydrate,” Ratcliffe said. “The most recent Cochrane review concluded that addressing the quality of fat in the diet could reduce cardiovascular events by 14% and perhaps that is worthy of consideration.”

Professor of Nutritional Metabolism at the University of Surrey, Bruce Griffin, added: “A more balanced review of the overall evidence would reveal that the risks from saturated fat and refined sugars are not mutually exclusive, but co-exist together in our diet. …Nutritional science is complex and imperfect, making it feasible to construct logical and compelling arguments that either one of these dietary components can exert more or less cardiovascular risk.”

The commentary comes on the heels of a Swedish study that suggested saturated fats were indeed linked to disease risk, influencing heart disease risk, cholesterol levels and where fat is stored in the body.

DiNicolantonio’s commentary is available online here.

Related News

‘Weak’ evidence for red meat link with cancer, scientists claim

‘Weak’ evidence for red meat link with cancer, scientists claim

Dietary guidelines that suggest cutting out saturated fats and increasing polyunsaturated fats such as omega-3s may not be based on the evidence, according to a new meta analysis.

Further evidence questions fat intake guidelines and heart disease links

Should dietary guidelines about saturated fat be changed?

Should dietary guidelines about saturated fat be changed?

Stephen T. Sinatra MD, FACN: 'It was never saturated fat that was killing us, it's been sugar all the time'

Saturated fat in the dock: ‘Our nutritional courts tried and convicted the wrong man’

Carbs, not just fat, may influence blood lipid levels

Carbs, not just fat, may influence blood lipid levels

Bunge's John Jansen: "In order to get away from trans and saturated fat, end users have been hesitant to just add in palm oil at 48% saturates. When they’re trading small levels of trans fats for more highly saturated fats, most end users don’t want to make wholesale changes to palm oil unless no alternatives are available.”

Progress on PHOs and why saturated fat is still bad: Bunge

Andy Bellatti: There have been strides made in that it’s important to differentiate among kinds of fats, but there’s still too much low-fat emphasis in federal recommendations."

Gallup: Americans still avoid fat over carbs; RD says still too much federal emphasis on low fat

Dr Steve Zeisel:  “In pregnancy we know that low choline diets are associated with increased rates of birth defects."

90% of Americans don't get enough choline. So why isn't it higher up the food policy agenda?

Skeptics question conclusion that limiting saturated fat unfounded

Skeptics question researchers’ conclusion that recommendation to limit saturated fat unfounded

BHF joins calls for caution on controversial back-to-the-80s fat study

BHF joins calls for caution on controversial back-to-the-80s fat study

Is salt linked to obesity? Study links adolescent salt intake to obesity and inflammation

Is salt linked to obesity? Study links adolescent salt intake to obesity and inflammation

The risk of dying from heart disease increased exponentially with the amount of added sugars consumed

Sugar consumption linked to heart disease death risk

"Voluntary initiatives are failing to protect children," the IASO says

Governments must regulate to curb obesity: IASO

Exercise can't compensate for too much dietary fat, the researchers say

Teens’ fat intake more important than exercise for abdominal fat: Study

Obesity myths: Overweight can not be healthy

'Healthy and overweight' is a myth, say researchers

Dietary fats: The good, the bad and the ugly...

Dietary fats: The good, the bad and the ugly...

Is butter really so bad for you?

Cardiologist aims to bust saturated fat ‘myth’

Related Products

See more related products