Catch 22: Sustainable fishing produces massive carbon emissions

Buying sustainably caught fish may be bad for the environment ©iStock

Whilst smaller scale sustainable fishing practices protect the oceans from depletion of marine life, they are vastly more detrimental to the environment, say researchers

A report by researchers at University of California Merced (UCM) last month revealed that sustainable tuna fishing may have enormous consequences for other aspects of the environment.

Use of ‘selective’ fishing techniques reduces the amount of fish caught by traditional techniques like seine fishing but selective processes require up to four times the amount of fuel.

Seine fishing sweeps large areas of the sea and often decimates the population and catches other species by accident.

However, by selecting ‘economic zones’ for sustainable fishing, more boats are required and carbon emissions increase rapidly.

It is estimated that catching a tonne of tuna today requires three times the amount of fuel it did 25 years ago.

Rising sea levels are a major threat to the fishing industry, and current sustainable practices may be inadvertently speeding the process up.

Hook, line and sinker

Consumers globally are increasingly calling for more clarity on the origin of their seafood.

A series of reports released by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ) exposing the mass depletion of sea food, widespread illegal fishing and mislabelling, caused a public outcry in 2010.

Besides fears for the eco system, consumers face increasing awareness that the fish on their plate may be mislabelled. A review released last year showed up to a third of fish in supermarkets and restaurants is incorrectly marked - often substituted with cheaper varieties.  

As a result, labelling for sustainably caught seafood has become rife, helping the eco-conscious diner select ocean-friendly and reliable products more easily.

However, no such standards are yet in place for carbon emissions.

Carbon labelling

The Marine Stewardship Council (MSC), a non-profit organisation, has developed an international labelling system to mark all fish products guaranteed as sustainably caught and correctly labelled.

Today the MSC boasts 10% of the world’s commercial fish are certified by its blue label, with 281 global fisheries adhering to its standards.

A spokesperson for MSC told FoodNavigator it currently has no plans to include carbon emissions as part of the standards required for receiving the blue label.  

However, with the revelations of increased carbon emissions, Austral Fishery in Western Australia, an MSC certified fishery, has taken it upon itself to become the first ‘carbon neutral’ fishery in the world.

MSC chief executive Rupert Howes said: “Climate change is the biggest single sustainability challenge humanity faces. I congratulate Austral Fisheries for their bold and innovative initiative”.

Related News

iStock ©

Slavery at sea prompts calls for new ethical seafood labelling

Is Haddock off the menu after being labelled 'one to avoid'? iStock©

Scottish Fisherman’s Federation labels haddock sustainability rating 'vandalism'

According to the report, incidences of slavery, murder and public intimidation are common in the Thai Kingdom's billion dollar fishing industry ©iStock

UN slams Thailand for 'government corruption' behind slavery in fisheries


EU launches new sustainable fisheries project to fight climate change threats


Could banning cargo offloading put an end to seafood malpractice?

© iStock

MSC's 2020 strategy: One fifth of seafood certified sustainable by 2020

© iStock/PicturePartners

Do consumers really care about the ethical considerations of fishing?

This increase in anthropogenic pressure, along with climate change, threatens the biodiversity of fishes and food security. ©iStock

Higher marine food demand places big fish on ‘at risk’ list, study finds

© iStock

New €7 m project aims to ensure all European aquaculture businesses are sustainable and competitive

© iStock

Idaho producer ups sustainability effort with recycled fish feed ingredient

© iStock/chengyuzheng

What can fish protein hydrolysate offer farmed turbot?

© brianskerry

How is Coppens reducing the fish in, fish out ratio?

A fish market in Istanbul. ©iStock/Manakin

Mislabelled fish could be the sustainable choice, especially in cases of fraud - but there's a catch

© istock/RomoloTavani

Pledge seen as ‘breakthrough’ for seafood industry sustainability

Market growth has been primarily driven by South America and the Asia-Pacific region

Seafood market set for continued growth

Comments (1)

Clarice - 11 Jan 2017 | 02:10

Transport inefficiencies outweigh catch effort

The transport related emissions of the seafood supply chain far outweigh the fuel expended in catching fish. For instance, 90% of the seafood consumed by Americans was caught or farmed in another country. More focus should be given to eating local, sustainable resources.

11-Jan-2017 at 02:10 GMT

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.