US, EU can reach compromise on geographical indications: EDA

US, EU can reach compromise on geographical indications: EDA

The European Dairy Association (EDA) is confident EU and US Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) negotiators can reach a compromise on the "lingering issue" of geographical indications (GIs).

Speaking with DairyReporter.com, Alexander Anton, secretary general, EDA, said that US and European Union (EU) TTIP representatives will likely meet each other half way on the issue of GIs. 

“We invite the European Commission to protect our geographical indications," said Anton, "but if we need to find a compromise we will find one."

GI products are categorized under the protected designation of origin (PDO) and protected geographical indication (PGI) schemes, which identify a good as originating in a particular region or locality where a "given quality, reputation or other characteristic" is essentially attributable to its geographical origin. 

Feta, Edam, Gouda, Grana Padano, Parmigiano Reggiano (Parmesan), Comté and Roquefort are among the scores of European cheese names protected by the GI system.

US products, using GI-protected food names such as Feta, cannot be sold in the EU. If the same policy is transferred to the US under the TTIP, dairy processors and supply dairy farmers would be affected, the US Dairy Export Council (USDEC) has warned.

"Lingering issue"

Yesterday, on the back of a stakeholder meeting with US and EU negotiators during the latest round of TTIP talks in Brussels, USDEC issued a statement refusing to consider any suggestion that US cheese producers should give up their right to use common food names on the US market.

Around 95% of these GIs pose no problem, said USDEC. But the EU's protection of generic names such as Feta and Parmesan (Parmigiano Reggiano) constitutes a "lingering issue in the EU-US negotiations," it said.

“We believe it is reasonable for product with a specific geographic designation included in their compound name to be protected, such as Gouda Holland or Brie de Melun. The names Gouda and Brie remain unrestricted, which means that when used in combination with a regional name the protection does no distort trade,” said USDEC representative, Maike Moellers.

“The reality is, however, that the US and most other countries already provide the opportunity to protect terms such as these.”

“What we strongly oppose is the EU’s overreaching approach to restrict in the EU and in third countries via FTAs, the use of common, generic names, claiming that these products can only come from specific regions in Europe. This results in the elimination of competition and provides commercial advantages to certain EU manufacturers,” said Moellers. 

Canadian "compromise"

TTIP negotiations began in July 2013 with the aim of removing trade barriers between the EU and US. Research suggests that the deal could provide the EU and US economies with a boost of €120bn (US$162bn) and €90bn (US$121bn) respectively. 

To "avoid that this issue becomes a stumbling block" USDEC has called for GIs to be remove from the TTIP and "dealt with in a separate forum in order to carefully assess the legitimate concerns of both sides."

EDA, which represents the interests of the European dairy sector, is confident, however, that some sort of compromise - like the one agreed between the EU and Canada - on EU GIs can be reached.

After more than four years of negotiation, the EU and Canada reached an agreement on the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement, including a section on GIs.Under CETA, Canada was given limited GI rights on several cheese names, including Asiago, Feta, and Gorgonzola.

Current users of the common food names, Asiago, Feta and Gorgonzola, can continue using such terms under the agreement. Future users will, however, only be permitted to use the GI-protected names if accompanied by terms such as 'type', 'style', or 'imitation'. 

“It has always been a critical issue for the US and it is of great importance to the EU,” said Anton. “Since we fought for a compromise with our friends in Canada, we are sure there will be a compromise with our friends in the US.”

Related News

A positive outcome of TTIP talks would, for example, allow the export of US-made Feta "labelled as such" to the EU, says USDEC.

Canada-style EU GI cheese compromise 'entirely unacceptable': USDEC

A free trade agreement between the EU and USA could undermine food security efforts, says German NGO Brot für die Welt.

EU-US trade agreement may undermine global food security

The European trade commissioner has urged pressure groups to keep the transatlantic trade deal discourse ‘factual and rational’ in a response to criticism.

Commission has not misled on transatlantic trade impact, says letter to lobbyists

"This is the thin end of the wedge in the campaign by industry to force GM foods into Europe," says Friends of the Earth Europe

TTIP is a 'trojan horse' trade deal for GM imports, says Friends of the Earth

European Council declassifies TTIP trade negotiation document

European Council declassifies TTIP trade negotiation document

USDEC, CCFN 'absolutely reject' Canadian GI compromise as 'model for TTIP'

USDEC, CCFN 'absolutely reject' Canadian GI compromise as 'model for TTIP'

Saputo 'should be involved' in the allocation of additional EU cheese quota

Saputo 'should be involved' in the allocation of additional EU cheese quota

NMPF calls for framework to determine 'legitimate' European GIs in TTIP talks

NMPF calls for framework to determine 'legitimate' European GIs in TTIP talks

Canada dismisses Greek call to drop feta exports from trade talks

Canada dismisses Greek call to drop feta cheese exports from trade talks

Italy blocks EU-Costa Rica trade deal over cheese GI infringements

Italy blocks EU-Costa Rica trade deal over cheese GI infringements

Cheeses, including Feta, are protected under the EU geographical indication (GI) scheme.

EU geographical indication scheme ‘over-reach’ blocking dairy trade - USDEC

Cheeses, including Roquefort, are protected under the EU geographical indication (GI) scheme.

Geographical indication-protected cheese sales hit €6.3bn – EC report

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.