France considers ‘traffic light’ labelling as UK MEP hits back at EU threat of court case

French health minister proposes new preventative public health law, which could see the country adopting a similar nutrition labelling system to the UK's 'traffic light' scheme.

France's health minister has put forward plans for the country’s own ‘traffic light’ nutrition labelling system; meanwhile a UK Member of the European Parliament (MEP) has defended the UK’s debated colour-coded system against the threat of a “spurious legal case” that could be instigated by the Commission.

The French food industry could have its own colour coded nutrition labelling system to contend with as part of French health minister Marisol Touraine’s proposal for a new public health law which holds simplification, innovation and prevention as key axes. The text will be presented to the French Council of Ministers in September, and will be debated in parliament from the beginning of 2015.

Last week the European Commission told FoodNavigator it was investigating whether the UK’s existing ‘traffic light’ front-of-pack labelling was compatible with EU law. If it was found lacking, an infringement procedure, referral to the European Court of Justice (ECJ) and possible fines could follow, it said.

Responding to the development, Glenis Willmott, health spokesperson for UK Labour MEPs, said: “I strongly condemn attempts to stop the traffic light scheme through a spurious legal case.”

“The EU legislation is clear that individual countries can implement voluntary labelling schemes, which is exactly what is happening in the UK. Whilst a lot of retailers and some producers have signed up, nobody is forced to. Similar schemes exist in other EU member states, such as the keyhole scheme used in Nordic countries,” Willmott said.

French proposals

The French minister claims the new bill will be the first in France to recognise disease prevention as a basic tool in public health policy. Discussing the proposals, Touraine described what she called the preservation of "health capital".

According to reports from French national Le Monde, the packaging will be colour coded in a similar way to the UK system illustrating sugar, fat, salt and calorie content of foods but using a five-colour code - green, yellow, orange, fuchsia and red - as opposed to the UK's traffic-light three.  

A petition by medical organisations and consumer groups in support of improved food labelling already has over 22,000 signatures, the newspaper reported.

An ongoing story for the UK and the EU

The UK already has its own voluntary so called ‘traffic light’ nutrition labelling system – which ranks sugars, fat, saturated fatty acids and salt by colour – red, green or amber – depending on content levels. This is in addition to Guideline Daily Amount (GDA) information, which has been mandatory across the EU since 2010 after the the European Parliament voted against pan-EU implementation of a traffic light system.

Traffic lights have sparked opposition from those who feel the system fragments EU standards at a time when efforts are being made to harmonise EU law, while others argue it is discriminatory and overly simplistic in its classification of multi-component foods.

The Commission’s latest investigation follows several complaints from European companies expressing concerns over the impact of the system.

Responding, Willmott said: “After heavy industry lobbying defeated my proposals for EU-wide traffic light labelling, some in the industry are now trying to stop a perfectly legitimate national scheme.”

She added: “The easiest and most effective way to implement the traffic light scheme with legal certainty would be through EU legislation, and I think this is something we could still achieve in the future.”

“Consumers like the traffic light scheme because it gives them the information they need to make quick, informed decisions. If we’re serious about tackling obesity and related diseases like heart disease, cancer and diabetes, then we need to be transparent about what is in our food."

Related News

Reactions to food labelling vary depending on consumer socioeconomic status, according to new research using popcorn.

Reactions to food labels vary by socioeconomic status

"It can raise prices, it can scare off companies. It can stifle innovation because the fear is you're going to get hit with a class action," says lawyer.

If France moves towards US-style class actions, innovation will be stifled: Lawyer

Swedish survey shows need for more products that adhere to Nordic nutrition keyhole label standards

80% of Swedes give keyhole labelling thumbs up

The Commission has sent a formal letter to the UK, opening proceedings against the UK's 'traffic light' label, which could see the state facing court action.

Commission opens infraction proceedings against UK’s 'traffic light' label

The Commission has initiated legal proceedings against the UK's traffic light system - so why aren't any other labelling schemes facing the same problem?

UK's traffic light label is 'negative', says Commission

Too many front-of-pack logos are problematic for business, says Unilever's Paul Whitehouse

WHO calls for standardised nutrition labelling

UK MEP says the traffic light label scheme adheres to all points laid out by the EU Food Information to Consumers Regulation

Don’t challenge UK traffic light label, make it EU-compulsory, MEP tells commissioners

Colour-coded schemes have been endorsed by major food companies, says BEUC

FIC regs ‘missed opportunity’ for mandatory front of pack labelling

Red traffic light labels activated a part of the brain associated with self-control in food choice

Traffic light labels may improve self-control

The till-based receipt aims to evaluate the nutritional content of a consumer’s entire supermarket trolley. ©Hayden Peek.

Receipt-based traffic light system could aid in making healthier food choices

UK ‘traffic light’ labels could be taken to EU courts of justice

EU Commission could take UK and its ‘traffic light’ labels to courts of justice

UK traffic light labelling could harm Italian traditional foods

Italy says UK traffic light labelling could harm traditional foods

Multinationals won't adopt the system unless it is mandatory across the EU, says Willmott

Only EU regulation can ensure traffic light compliance, says MEP

“This moves the focus away from a stop or go interpretation and shifts this towards an emphasis on getting the right balance of foods in the diet and making informed choices,” says BHF dietician.

A question of semantics: From ‘traffic light’ to ‘colour coded’ labelling

Traffic light labels inspire low fat choices: Study

Low-fat choices likelier with traffic light labels, finds study

STOP fussing over UK traffic light labelling

STOP fussing over UK traffic light labelling

EU to reassess UK traffic light labels

EU to reassess UK traffic light labels

UEAPME: SMEs concerned about UK hybrid nutrition labels

UK traffic light labels could harm European SMEs, says industry body

Combined traffic light and GDA labelling may improve teens’ food choices: Study

Combined traffic light and GDA labelling may improve teens’ food choices: Study

Related Products

See more related products

Comments (3)

Corrado Finardi - 14 Jul 2014 | 04:20

What when nutrient profiles will be in place?

National labeling schemes are now taking momentum due to the lack of pan-european nutrition profiles as from art. 4 of reg. 1924/2006. I wonder what will be of the legitimacy of such schemes when nutrient profiles-with different evaluation metric- will be in place. However, we should be aware that the increasing attention paid to "Cop labeling" may be deemed as a symptom of the impotence against present "tricky" food chains. We could be aware that labeling while reassuring for policy makers, is not the solution.

14-Jul-2014 at 16:20 GMT

lisa - 27 Jun 2014 | 03:37

misleading food labelling

this labelling did not change the purchasing habits of consumers and did not decrease the obesity rate in the UK! quite the contrary, it's misleading consumers: they avoid saturated fats which are essential for a balanced diet.

27-Jun-2014 at 15:37 GMT

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.