FIC label changes could break organic rules

Organic food producers making changes to labels to comply with FIC regulations must be careful not to accidentally break organic rules.

Organic food firms changing their packaging to meet new EU labelling rules could accidentally breach organic labelling rules in the process, one certifier has warned.

The Organic Farmers & Growers (OF&G), a leading organic control body, is concerned that organic food processors will be caught out by the assumption that any changes do not need to be checked by their organic control body.

The new EU Food Information for Consumers (FIC) regulation sets out a standardised format for food information on product packaging, including the way allergens are distinguished, how nutritional information is displayed and font size. FIC is known as Food Information Regulations (FIR) in UK law.

Most food and drink labels will need changing before the December 13 deadline. In terms of organic regulations, nothing has changed. However, the issue arises because of other aspects of the new labelling requirements.

"Everyone is working hard to ensure they meet the new FIR requirements but I think that because they are not related directly to the organic regulation, they often come to the conclusion that control bodies do not need to be involved," explained OF&G processor certification officer, Ruth Lamb.

"We are finding that design houses can change an aspect of the label that they consider insignificant, for example amending the mandatory EU organic logo dimensions or amending the specific wording in the ingredients panel, which could then put the product in breach of the law relating to organic products.”

Possible pitfalls

Organic regulations state “the list of ingredients shall indicate which ingredients are organic”. When amending ingredient panels for allergens, there have been cases where the panel was altered while forgetting to identify some ingredients as organic.

In addition, the size of the EU organic logo can been changed when moving it. There is a minimum size for this logo.

To fit in wording or when labels have been altered, positioning of text has been changed. Specific text, such as the control body code, must be in the same visual field as the EU organic logo. If the EU logo is moved, the text may not be.

The EU agricultural statement must be directly below the control body code. When moving text, some have not moved the statement with the code, noted Lamb.

Planning ahead

Companies are advised to seek timely feedback from their organic control body on any changes, to avoid expensive mistakes.

OF&G warned that it may face increased demand for its services, as is the case for design houses and specialist printers, particularly as the December deadline approaches. Therefore there may not be time to rectify mistakes discovered late in the day.

A similar issue was also raised by Reading Scientific Services Ltd (RSSL) earlier this year, which highlighted the finite number of companies that print packaging and urged manufacturers to get their label orders in early.

Related News

FIC gluten-free labeling: Logos remain outside the remit of FIC, the European Commission ruled [Pictured: Coeliac UK's crossed grain symbol]

‘Important changes’ as gluten-free label laws move under FIC

The UK Food Standards Agency has published new guidelines to help small and medium sized businesses meet new allergen labelling rules.

FIC update: UK publishes advice for SMEs on food allergen labelling

“When people buy something labelled ‘organic’, especially when accompanied by the EU’s official organic logo, they expect that product to be genuinely organic: i.e. with minimal – and ideally zero – chemical additives and with no non-organic inputs during the production process,” said Adam Smith, science and communications officer at ANH

EU organic rules may mean certified food is not truly organic, warns ANH

Eleven of 20 sampled products were found to comply with the new rules, which are due to come into effect on December 13.

FIC countdown: Most food companies are moving toward compliance

It’s legal but dishonest to use non-organic aromas in organic products, says consumer group Foodwatch

Organic aroma loophole leaves bad taste

'We are not living in an organic world, but we are doing our best to improve that world,' says organic yoghurt brand criticised for its use of a non-organic ingredient

Vrai bats off 100% organic criticism: We used what was available

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.