EU organic rules may mean certified food is not truly organic, warns ANH

“When people buy something labelled ‘organic’, especially when accompanied by the EU’s official organic logo, they expect that product to be genuinely organic: i.e. with minimal – and ideally zero – chemical additives and with no non-organic inputs during the production process,” said Adam Smith, science and communications officer at ANH

The Alliance for Natural Health suggests that non-organic inputs may be used in EU organic production until 31st December 2017 and call the public to action in support of true organic agriculture. 

In its recent article “When ‘organic’ doesn’t really mean organic in the European Union”, ANH demonstated how EU has permitted the use of non-organic food in ‘organic’ production until 2017. Moreover, the EU standards still allow the use of various additives in organic production.

“We find it shocking that the EU permits so many additives in organic products – over 40 in EU-certified organic wine, for example – and continues to sanction several non-organic agricultural inputs,” said Adam Smith, science and communications officer at ANH.

“When people buy something labelled ‘organic’, especially when accompanied by the EU’s official organic logo, they expect that product to be genuinely organic: i.e. with minimal – and ideally zero – chemical additives and with no non-organic inputs during the production process,” he added. 

Section 2 of Commission Regulation (EC) No. 889/2008 defined circumstances where non-organic inputs such as poultry, beeswax, feed, seeds etc. may be used in EU production. It originally expired in 2011, was subsequently extended to the end of 2014 and would now remain in place until 31st December 2017.

As a result organic farms would still be allowed to use non-organic feed for poultry meat and egg production as well as up to 5% non-organic feed for pigs.

Call to action

ANH ‘call to action’ gave the public a chance to back their efforts towards fully organic food.  It encouraged people to go for organic box schemes, go shopping locally, take up its ‘Barcode-Free Challenge’, grow own products or even explore WWOOF (Worldwide Opportunities on Organic Farms).

“EU regulation is driven overwhelmingly by the large food and supplier businesses. Therefore, the most significant pressures to reform the regulatory situation will come from two primary directions.  One is certification organisations like the Soil Association; and the other is public pressure,” Smith told Food Navigator.

“People often ask us “But what can we do?” in response to the issues we raise in our work; in this case, we tried to point people toward sources of organic food that are unlikely to contain the non-organic inputs and additives allowed in EU-certified organic products,” he added.

Related News

The new method was able to accurately distinguish whether more than 350 samples of tomatoes were organic or conventional produce.

Researchers take aim at organic food fraud

"“All institutions argue about strengthening consumer trust.... Annual inspections are important for securing trust in the soundness of organic certification," said IFOAM

EU regulatory deadlock welcomed by organic groups

BioFach 2016 Organic trends, innovations & hot topics

Organic trends, innovations & hot topics: What's the buzz at BioFach?

'It’s the choice of feed, not the organic farming method, which makes the difference,' food chain nutrition expert, Professor Ian Givens. iStock / DigitalZombie

Organic meat & dairy has more omega-3 but amounts aren't 'nutritionally relevant'


Despite price incentives, organic feed may face growth challenges in the US


US: Iowa gets organic feed mill


Cornucopia Institute files lawsuit against the USDA

Bird type, forage options play role in organic hen production

Bird type, forage options play role in organic hen production

© iStock

US organic report shows increase in overall sales, downturn for feed crops

© New Country Organics

US: New Country Organics looks to expand feed footprint

© iStock

Volume, infrastructure, awareness top challenges for US organic market

© iStock

US: Organic premix and feed facility opens in Iowa

© iStock/bluebay2014

Capital released for US farmers transitioning to organic

© iStock

Fungal supplement may reduce parasite load in organic dairy calf systems

© iStock

Study questions whether organic dairy products should claim a premium

© iStock

Proposed US organic checkoff comment period nears close

© iStock

Reports of falsely labeled organic feed drive industry concerns

Research has suggested that the amount of processing of organic foods seems to be negatively associated with sales, suggesting that the nutritional benefits of consuming organic ingredients are somehow lost in processing. ©iStock/leventalbas

Lost in processing? Organic’s ‘halo effect’ blunted in processed food

© iStock

USDA pulls organic importer certification from Turkish company Beyaz Agro after fraud questions

© iStock/abluecup

Montana Specialty Mills starts work on $20m facility

The size of the organic farming market within the EU has grown by more than 50% in the past 10 years, according to new statistics.

Organic farming on rise in Europe, say officials EU officials

Organic food producers making changes to labels to comply with FIC regulations must be careful not to accidentally break organic rules.

FIC label changes could break organic rules

UK organic sales rose by 2.8% to £1.79bn last year, according to the Soil Association

Producers urged to return to organic

Related Products

See more related products

Comments (4)

Simon Williams - 19 Aug 2014 | 07:22

Meanwhile in the real world...

If the authorities did not allow the derogations on feeding non-organic ingredients to pigs and poultry there would be huge animal welfare issues and the price of the remaining organic products would be totally unaffordable. The ANH are essentially campaigning for their own demise, a case of organic turkeys voting for Christmas perhaps?

19-Aug-2014 at 19:22 GMT

Katie Owens - Hi Peak Feeds - 20 Aug 2014 | 06:30

Organic Feed

Please note that not all organic pig and poultry feeds are manufactured using only 95% organic agricultural ingredients. Hi Peak Organic Feeds is the only UK manufacturer who has made organic pig and poultry diets using 100% organic agricultural ingredients; it has done this successfully for a number of years with no adverse impact on animal performance or health.

20-Aug-2014 at 18:30 GMT

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.