Nearly 2/3 UK bread contain pesticide residues, report claims

"The interpretation of the report by PAN UK is simply scaremongering consumers into thinking bread is not a healthy food choice," says the Federation of Bakers.

A report from lobby group Pesticide Action Network (PAN UK) claims nearly two thirds of UK bread tested between 2000 and 2013 contained pesticide residues, but DEFRA says there is no threat to human health.

Using data collected by the UK’s Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA), the report claimed this ‘contamination’ posed a risk to consumer health, urging consumers to switch to organic and calling for greater restrictions on pesticides used in the UK.  

DEFRA responded to the claims, stating: “There is no human health risk from pesticide residues in bread. Levels of pesticide residue in food are minimal and we have strict testing methods in place to check this.”

Industry association Federation of Bakers said it was deeply concerned” by the report, which it said was “scaremongering” on “approved, regulated and legal” pesticides and bias towards the organic sector.    

PAN UK suggested the relationship between pesticide companies, DEFRA and the National Farmers’ Union was too cosy, jeopardizing public safety. 

Cause for concern?

According to the PAN report: “Between 2000 and 2013, 2951 bread samples were tested by the PRiF committee [DEFRA’s expert committee on Pesticide Residues in Food], 2909 of these were non organic and the remaining 42 were organic bread products. Over that period 61.49% of the non- organic samples were found to contain pesticide residues, 17.12% containing more than one pesticide residue.”

Weed-killer glyphosate and plant growth regulator chlormequat were the most frequently found pesticide residues, with occasional instances of insecticides pirimiphos methyl, malathion and mepiquat also recorded. 

PAN UK claims the impact of some of these pesticides could range from bio-accumulation to cancer, birth defects, neurological disease and developmental toxicity.

The organization said the steadily increasing trend in both the number of positive tests and those testing positive for more than one pesticide was a, “cause for concern”.

However, the Federation of Bakers said:The interpretation of the report by PAN UK is simply scaremongering consumers into thinking bread is not a healthy food choice.”

It said the official DEFRA expert report, on which the PAN UK report was based, concluded, “quite clearly that there are no negative impacts on health from any of the residues detected on bread”. The federation said it was also crucial to acknowledge that all detected levels were “considerably lower” than the internationally agreed maximum residue limit (MRL).

For bread the original PRiF committee report concluded: "We would not expect any of the residues detected by the laboratory to have an effect on health." 

Organic vs conventional

Looking at organic breads, the report found none to contain multiple residues, but 7% contained a single pesticide residue. “The most likely explanation for this is cross-contamination from non-organic, either during production or storage. This raises the issue of how we can prevent conventional agricultural methods undermining the integrity of organic."

The Federation of Bakers said: The fact that they [PAN UK] are a group whose primary objective is to promote organic products means that they have a vested interest in the messages they are putting across. Unlike the DEFRA expert group, they are not an independent or scientific voice, and have given consumers incorrect and misleading advice.”

PAN's report followed the release of a UK national action plan on pesticides by DEFRA in March. 

Related News

Food imports from Malaysia, Laos, Cambodia and Kenya flout maximum pesticides residue levels most frequently

How much pesticide residue is in our food?

'Private investors could help manufacturers to recuperate profits,' says Euromonitor food analyst

Burnt toast? Packaged bread needs investors, not innovation

Will Flowers be able to spring America's organic bread market to life after Dave's Killer Bread buy?

Organic bread may be difficult for Flowers to popularize, says analyst

Manufacturers are contributing to farmers' reliance on pesticides by refusing to use resistant crops for aesthetic reasons, according to INRA researcher Jean-Marc Meynard. © iStock/Fotokostic

French consumer group finds cocktail of pesticide residues on fruit samples

EFSA found 2.9% of 82,649 food samples exceeded maximum reside levels (MRLs), a level it said was acceptable. ©iStock/fotokostic

Pesticide data suggests EU food is safe; campaigners disagree

Health risk from pesticide residues is low, says EFSA

Health risk from pesticide residues is low, says EFSA

French firm adds five new bread mixes to its Campasine range

Philibert Savours CEO: Organic cuts my world in two

An organic label will not turn potato chips into a health food, report says

The power of organic: Turning snacks into health foods?

Study reveals the ‘health halo’ of organic foods

Study reveals the ‘health halo’ of organic foods

Organic production on the up – but field crops still struggle

Related Products

See more related products

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.