Clean label isn't as big as industry thinks, says DuPont

Not all consumers want clean label, it has been 'over-emphasized', says DuPont

Demonization of ingredients and a lack of consumer understanding has fueled clean label, but it remains niche among a small group of consumers, DuPont Nutrition & Health says. 

The emulsifier and enzyme specialist is among the many companies trying to decipher what clean label means to consumers and thus what it means for industry. DuPont conducted a global consumer survey across 10 cities to investigate what consumers associate with ‘clean label’.

Speaking exclusively to BakeryandSnacks.com the team from the bakery and fats & oils department at DuPont Nutrition & Health said that while clean label is a trend, it has been “over-emphasized”.

“There is this demonization of ingredients which is driving the cleaner label trend,” said Janelle Crawford, strategic marketing lead for bakery, fats and oils at DuPont Nutrition & Health.

“Consumers don’t know a lot about ingredients – there’s a real lack of understanding. So to them, for natural or clean label, they think about how much processing it has gone through,” she said.

This means that an apple sauce – that contains mashed apples with cinnamon and is packaged – is considered less natural because it’s gone through lots of processing steps, she explained.

When it comes to consumer understanding on individual ingredients, Troy Boutte, group manager for bakery and fats & oils at DuPont Nutrition & Health, said that trans fats are a good example of consumer confusion.

Trans fats became associated with ‘hydrogenated’ on the label, but when fully hydrogenated, as opposed to partially, there are no trans fats, he said.

Similarly, some compounds like mono-glycerides (used as emulsifiers in food), that naturally occur in the human gut and are needed, scare off consumers on a label, he added.

The clean label boom? 

No-one seems to know where the clean label demand, if there is a demand, is coming from, says Troy Boutte, group manager for bakery and fats & oils at DuPont Nutrition & Health

Industry must be careful in assuming that the clean label demand is strong and that it’s coming from consumers, he continued.

“One thing that we’re finding is that no-one seems to know where that demand, if there is a demand, is coming from. It seems to be coming from marketing. I mean, there’s no doubt that there is a subset of the population that is very interested in cleaner label products, no doubt. But I think we are jumping to conclusions to some extent – saying that people want clean label and are driving everyone else,” he said.

There is a group of consumers who do want clean label, but you also have a group of consumers who do not care at all, he said. Then there is a middle more pragmatic group, who base purchasing decisions on whether the price is right, if it tastes good and if it looks reasonably healthy, he said,

Crawford said that findings from the global survey indicated that very few consumers looked closely at the ingredients list on products – it was more about the front of pack and nutrition information. Packaging, colors, simplicity and text also heavily influence purchase decisions, she said.

For example, she said consumers associate baked goods from in-store bakeries to be 'healthier' because they are baked in store and packaged very simply, but understand the shorter shelf life. They still purchase packaged sandwich bread, she said, because they are not willing to compromise on shelf life all the time - there is a need for both.

“So when you combine [the lack of close ingredients reading] with the lack of understanding about what those ingredients are, I think there can be an over-emphasis on a clean label trend that may not be driven by most consumers; the majority of people that we’re trying to feed,” she said. It is all about perspective, she added.

Stepping up to educate

Asked if ingredients companies should rally together to better educate consumers on ingredients and the concept of clean label, Boutte said that it could be done but isn’t justified because there hasn’t been a negative impact on business as DuPont caters to both clean label and regular demands.

Crawford said that it’s an interesting idea, but one that DuPont is not ready to tackle or certainly not do alone.

“I think the hard part is that there is no definition and we’re all just trying to understand a very broad topic in different ways…We’re not all speaking the same language,” she said. 

Related News

Univar: Cleaning up labels tops R&D agendas in 2014

Univar: Cleaning up labels tops R&D agendas in 2014

Kokke predicts Greek-style strained yoghurt is set to surge in popularity in Europe

Clean labels, transparency and the rise of Greek yoghurt: Ingredion talks top European trends

'While bakeries have a lot of concerns like everyone, two of their major ones are stale-free shelf life and mold-free shelf life,' says DuPont's bakery head

DuPont: Mold growth still a ‘major challenge’ for bakers

“Too many claims and the consumer is overwhelmed, but miss some out and you could be excluding a powerful motivator for purchase,” says Mintel analyst

Can too many simple ideas on pack get confusing?

Energy products & clean labels won't drive sales in 2015, NNB predicts

Energy products & clean labels will not drive sales in 2015, NNB predicts

New enzyme blend plugs clean label, quality high-fiber breads, says DuPont

High-fiber breads: Clean label and sensory pitfalls plugged, says DuPont

Natural colours overtake synthetics as European growth leads the way

Clean label trend helps drive natural colours to overtake synthetics

Ingredients and flavours drive double-digit development for Kerry

Are all-natural claims losing their luster? Find out at FoodNavigator-USA's Natural & Clean Label Trends FREE online event on June 26

Natural & Clean Label Trends 2013: How clean is your label? And can GMOs ever belong in 'natural' products?

Attorney: 'Judge Rogers recognizes that this is squarely a question for the FDA, not one that should be needlessly clogging up our court system'

Judge asks FDA to decide once and for all on whether GMOs belong in 'natural' products

While the Reb-A in Truvia products is derived from a natural source (the stevia leaf), the extraction and processing methods mean a reasonable consumer would no longer consider it to be ‘natural’, claims the lawsuit

Cargill hit with deceptive marketing lawsuit alleging Truvia stevia-based sweetener is not ‘natural’

Related Products

See more related products

Comments (1)

Hans Heezen - 08 Nov 2013 | 06:02

Food industry and retailers create "demand" for clean label

Agree with the authors experience and opinion, that clean label is "overemphasized by industry". I would say it is even created by the food industry and retailers for competitive reasons. It has started with the frequent and increasing use of negative claims (no artificial colours,etc), which actually undermines consumers'trust in food products and the industry

08-Nov-2013 at 18:02 GMT

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.