Guest article

Sugar tax reformulation: Could your company claim an R&D tax credit?

How can manufacturers make use of R&D tax reliefs to offset the investment costs and challenges? (©

The UK's sugar tax will spur some companies to reformulate. Here, a leading R&D tax consultant at Ayming UK explores how manufacturers can make full use of R&D tax reliefs to offset the investment costs and challenges.

One of the standout features of British finance minister George Osborne’s 2016 budget was the somewhat controversial announcement of a sugar tax on soft drinks, due to come into effect in 2018.

This presents manufacturers with a dilemma: pass the levy onto customers, take the hit themselves, or try to innovate and bring their products under the thresholds? Given the highly competitive nature of the market, the first two options may not be feasible for many.

But the innovation route is not easy either as tweaking a product to meet external requirements whilst maintaining brand consistency is a difficult undertaking.

Many customers will have consumed these products every day for much of their lives and are averse to the slightest changes. The smallest discrepancy can make a big dent in sales and reputation.

Navigating the reformulation minefield

The most obvious point here is taste – the high sugar content of many fizzy drinks goes a long way to defining their taste. Trying to achieve the same flavour with sugar substitutes – or more natural alternatives such as honey and nectar – can create problems.

Sprite’s decision to use stevia (a synthetic sugar alternative) is a case in point here. Stevia doesn’t taste quite the same as sugar and consumers can tell the difference: sales of Stevia-based Sprite crashed 9.4 per cent in the year following the change.

But the issue goes beyond just taste. The psychology associated with taste is complex, and branding and packaging can make a huge difference. The infamous Coke/Pepsi blind test trials are testament to this – many people prefer the taste of Pepsi when the brand is hidden, but find Coke ‘tastes better’ once the brand is known.

So, tweaking a recipe is a potential minefield. But there are broader manufacturing issues too. Outside of the large multinationals, many companies cannot afford to shut down existing production lines while they test new recipes.

Trial and error innovation

This can mean installing a second line in the meantime. This will require investment, but it also makes for a quality control issue. Even where the equipment being used is technically identical, new equipment can often make a big difference to the product’s taste.

All of this amounts to a prolonged and thorny ‘trial and error’ period for drinks companies looking to innovate around this problem. The first new recipe is unlikely to be right, and what works in the kitchen may not scale up well in the factory. So while 2018 may seem like a long way off, the timing is actually fairly tight; the technical processes will likely take from 6 to 18 months, and perhaps even longer considering the secretive nature of the


Do you qualify for an R&D tax credits?

Innovation will therefore mean major investment. However, what many don’t fully appreciate is that this investment needn’t represent a 100% loss. Much of this innovation can be potentially claimed for under the UK government’s research & development tax schemes.

What is particularly important for businesses is being aware of exactly what constitutes R&D in the eyes of HM Revenue and Customs. In this instance, research into new sugar substitutes and recipes is relatively obvious. However, its scope also reaches far beyond this to efforts less readily associated with ‘innovation’.

For example, the costs of activities such as trying different production methodologies, through to the design and development of equipment can often be claimed for under the R&D tax credits schemes. Similarly, developments to do with packaging, and advances in logistics and delivery for instance, may also qualify.

Even something as seemingly peripheral as new software to help machines and systems communicate more efficiently, can count too. And let’s not forget that time and money spent on ‘failed’ projects can be eligible as well.

For many drinks companies the next two years will be a period of intense innovation. For commercial reasons, many will have no choice but to embark on a substantial period of experimentation to comply with the sugar tax without reducing profits. The least they can do to offset these necessary costs is ensure they receive the tax breaks they are entitled to, in full.

Related News

From Mexico to Philadelphia; the UK to South Africa, a sugar tax is increasingly seen by policymakers as a way to combat rising obesity rates . ,Photo: iStock

From 'good sugar' to reformulation R&D: The companies that welcome sugar taxes

The UK food industry, the government and health campaigners will determine the country’s plan to tackle obesity, with the proposed sugar tax on soft drinks high in the agenda. ©iStock

Government reticence on sugar tax and obesity policy leaves everything to play for in bitter battle

In March this year, the UK government introduced a sugar tax on the soft drinks industry. ©iStock

Proposals outlining a tax on sugared drinks endorsed by WHO


Estonia gives green light to tax sugared soft drinks

The Chancellor's sugar tax budget bombshell could result in legal action

Sugar tax could spark industry legal action

Fat taxes 'may be counterproductive', says Danish tax ministry

Danish government scraps fat tax, cancels planned sugar tax

The soft drinks sugar tax could cost Coca-Cola £226M a year

Coca-Cola could face £226M sugar tax

Britvic will engage in the government consultation on the sugar tax this summer. Pic: iStock

Britvic ‘well placed’ to deal with UK sugar tax

Will the tax encourage companies to reformulate? Pic: iStock

UK sugar tax: The big questions

The UK's sugar tax will apply to beverages but not other food groups. Pic:iStock/OcusFocus

‘The way to tackle obesity is…’ ICBA president on alternatives to sugar tax

Related Products

See more related products

Submit a comment

Your comment has been saved

Post a comment

Please note that any information that you supply is protected by our Privacy and Cookie Policy. Access to all documents and request for further information are available to all users at no costs, In order to provide you with this free service, William Reed Business Media SAS does share your information with companies that have content on this site. When you access a document or request further information from this site, your information maybe shared with the owners of that document or information.